"I told Lucifer I am... was sleeping with Amaya. Or, well, I said enough for him to figure it out. Then he told Amaya something about her hurting me, and she avoided me for a week. Then Lucifer persuaded me to talk about it with Amaya, and she got really upset and said she was hurt, and that she could 'take or leave' the sex."

That last part still hurt so she was going to pretend it didn't.

"No one has ever said that to me!"